Current:Home > ScamsJudge dismisses antisemitism lawsuit against MIT, allows one against Harvard to move ahead -FinanceMind
Judge dismisses antisemitism lawsuit against MIT, allows one against Harvard to move ahead
View
Date:2025-04-13 10:26:24
BOSTON (AP) — A federal lawsuit accusing Massachusetts Institute of Technology of tolerating antisemitism after the Oct. 7 attacks in Israel has been dismissed while a similar one against Harvard University can continue.
The MIT lawsuit accused the university of approving antisemitic activities on campus and tolerating discrimination and harassment against Jewish students and faculty. In dismissing the lawsuit July 30, U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns noted that MIT took steps to address on-campus protests that posed a potential threat to Jewish students.
“Plaintiffs frame MIT’s response to the conflict largely as one of inaction. But the facts alleged tell a different story,” Stearns wrote. “Far from sitting on its hands, MIT took steps to contain the escalating on-campus protests that, in some instances, posed a genuine threat to the welfare and safety of Jewish and Israeli students, who were at times personally victimized by the hostile demonstrators.”
The judge drew a sharply different conclusion about Harvard, moving toward a trial on the university’s claim that it had done its best to balance its responsibilities of protecting free speech and preventing discrimination among its students.
Ruling on Aug. 6 that parts of that lawsuit can move forward, Stearns wrote that Harvard’s response to antisemitic incidents “was, at best, indecisive, vacillating, and at times internally contradictory.”
Fallout from the Israel-Hamas war roiled campuses across the United States during the last school year and reignited a debate over free speech.
College leaders have struggled to define the line where political speech crosses into harassment and discrimination, and both Arab and Jewish students have raised concerns that schools are doing too little to protect them. Some have complained that universities have gone too far in cracking down on pro-Palestinian protesters by arresting and suspending students, while others said they’ve been too tolerant of encampments that sprung up on campuses.
MIT said Thursday that the ruling in its case speaks for itself.
“We appreciate that the Court carefully assessed the allegations and dismissed plaintiffs’ claims,” MIT said in a statement. “Our leaders have and will continue to support our students and focus on making it possible for all of us to share the campus successfully while pursuing MIT’s vital mission.”
The StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice filed the lawsuit against MIT along with two students. Its director, Carly Gammill, expressed her disappointment on Thursday, saying they had sought to “hold MIT accountable for failing to protect Jewish and Zionist students from antisemitic hate on its campus.”
“We are immensely grateful to the courageous students and attorneys who made this case possible,” Gammill said. “The SCLJ will continue its efforts to hold bad actors responsible — whether for perpetuating or showing deliberate indifference to antisemitism — on behalf of students at MIT and campuses across the country.”
Students Against Antisemitism, Inc., accuses Harvard of violating Jewish students’ civil rights by tolerating them being harassed, assaulted and intimidated — behavior that has intensified since the Oct. 7 attack.
The judge Stearns dismissed the plaintiffs’ allegations that they were directly discriminated against by Harvard University. He said former president Claudine Gay and interim president Alan Garber repeatedly recognized “an eruption of antisemitism on the Harvard campus.”
But Stearns said there were many instances where the university “didn’t respond at all” and ”failed its Jewish students.”
“We are gratified that the Court has upheld our clients’ civil rights claims against Harvard,” Marc Kasowitz, a partner at the law firm that brought the suit, said in a statement. “We intend to continue to take all necessary and appropriate steps to protect Harvard’s Jewish students, the first step being discovery of Harvard’s internal files and communications to prove the full nature and extent of Harvard’s failures.”
In a statement, Harvard said it “will continue to take concrete steps to address the root causes of antisemitism on campus and protect our Jewish and Israeli students, ensuring they may pursue their education free from harassment and discrimination.
“We appreciate that the Court dismissed the claim that Harvard directly discriminated against members of our community, and we understand that the court considers it too early to make determinations on other claims,” the statement continued. “Harvard is confident that once the facts in this case are made clear, it will be evident that Harvard has acted fairly and with deep concern for supporting our Jewish and Israeli students.”
veryGood! (75)
Related
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- Fall Out Boy on returning to the basics and making the 'darkest party song'
- A music school uniting Syrian and Turkish cultures survives the massive earthquake
- The 92 Best Presidents’ Day Deals on Home, Tech, and Travel Products: Apple, Dyson, Roku, Ninja, and More
- Who are the most valuable sports franchises? Forbes releases new list of top 50 teams
- Stranger Things' David Harbour Shares Heartfelt Reaction to Noah Schnapp's Coming Out
- We're Russian To Finish 'Shadow And Bone'
- 'We Were Once a Family' exposes ills of U.S. child welfare system
- US wholesale inflation accelerated in November in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
- 'Love at Six Thousand Degrees' is a refreshing inversion of the trauma narrative
Ranking
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- 'Renfield' lacks bite
- Eco-idealism and staggering wealth meet in 'Birnam Wood'
- 'Schmigadoon!' co-creator says series was onspired by a 'love affair' with musicals
- Rylee Arnold Shares a Long
- We pack our knives and go deep on 'Top Chef'
- If you want to up your yogurt game, this Iranian cookbook will show you the whey
- La pregunta que llevó a una mujer a crear el primer archivo de reguetón puertorriqueño
Recommendation
Alex Murdaugh’s murder appeal cites biased clerk and prejudicial evidence
Rollicking 'Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves' scores a critical hit
In 'Showing Up,' Michelle Williams just wants to make some art
Hit animated film 'Moana' will receive a live-action remake, Disney announced
From family road trips to travel woes: Americans are navigating skyrocketing holiday costs
'The Super Mario Bros. Movie': It's-a meh!
Louis Tomlinson Holds Hands With Model Sofie Nyvang After Eleanor Calder Breakup
Biden taps Lady Gaga to co-chair an arts advisory committee that dissolved under Trump